What I Used to Believe
Early in practice, I thought the job of a medical provider was to answer questions well. When a patient came into the room with a concern, I explained the options, walked through the risks, and let them decide. That felt thorough. It felt fair. However, I was wrong and I was missing something important.
The Moment It Changed
I noticed a pattern over time. Patients would come in with a very specific idea of what they wanted, usually shaped by a photo, a friend’s result, or something that they had read. I would answer their questions and address their specific concerns. After the consultation, they would schedule the surgery, and the results would be successful by every technical measure. However, at times, the patient wasn’t fully satisfied, even when the surgery went well.
I realized that the problem wasn’t with the surgery. While I had addressed their verbal needs, I did not address their underlying concerns. When someone asks about a specific procedure, what they are really trying to resolve is how they feel when they look in the mirror or how they feel getting ready for an event. I found that taking a broader approach that also addressed how patients felt was more productive than focusing solely on the surgical procedure.
What I Do Differently Now
During the first consultation, I spend more time listening before I explain anything. I listen to what prompted them to come into the office and what was going on in their mind to reach out to me. As a result of active listening, my surgical recommendations may change or it changes how I explain the surgery because now I know what actually matters to them.
This takes longer. A consultation used to run twenty minutes now runs longer, because I’m not moving straight to options and risks. I ask what changed recently, what they’ve already tried, what result would actually feel like success to them. Patients aren’t always used to being asked that directly, so sometimes there’s a pause before they answer honestly.
Why This Matters More in Surgery Than Almost Anywhere Else
In most fields, if you misread what someone wants, you can adjust later. A bad haircut grows out. A wrong recommendation gets corrected next visit. Surgery doesn’t work that way. Once I’m in the operating room, the plan is the plan. If I got the goal wrong at the consult, there’s no fixing that afterward with a good technique. The technical part of this job is something I can control almost completely. Whether I understood the actual goal is something I only get one real chance to get right, at the start.
That’s part of why I moved away from thinking of a consult as a question-and-answer session. It’s closer to a conversation where my job is to find the real goal underneath the stated one, then explain honestly whether surgery is the right tool for that goal at all.
The Part That’s Hard to Teach
I don’t think this is something you can shortcut with a checklist. A list of questions to ask in every consult would help, but it wouldn’t catch the thing I’m actually describing, which is paying attention to what someone doesn’t say directly. Someone might describe a physical concern in detail but the tone shifts when they mention what’s coming up in their life: a wedding, returning to work, something they’ve been putting off. That shift is often more informative than the physical description.
I still ask the technical questions. Patients need clear information about recovery, risk, and what results are realistic. But I try not to let that information exchange become the whole consult. If I only answer what’s asked, I’ve done a competent job. If I figure out what’s underneath it, I’ve done the job that actually leads to a patient being glad they came in.
What I’d Tell Someone Earlier in Their Training
If I were talking to a resident starting out, I’d tell them the technical skills will come with repetition. Suturing, planning, judgment in the operating room, all of that improves the more you do it. What doesn’t improve automatically is the instinct to slow down at the start of a consult and actually listen for the real question. That’s a separate skill and it’s the one I wish someone had told me to work on sooner.